Bad Harold and Kumar movie reference aside there has been a big uproar over Flickr’s decision to include video into their previously photo only service. I read through some of the groups and messages of this “revolt” and nothing more than some eye rolling was produced. There is a lot being made about how the addition of video will add so much noise and kill the fine art photographers that have made Flickr such an important part of their work. The online version of “video killed the radio star” if you will. A few points.
First off, I love Flickr and its community. I have been a Flickr user for more than 4 years through 3k+ photos and 20k photo stream views. It has been instrumental in evolving my knowledge and appreciation for photography.
The Myspace-ification of Flickr has done more to kill fine art photography on the site than video will ever be able to do. People begging for comments on photos, making contests and little .gif awards and throwing them at every mediocre photo they can click just hoping their photos or group get attention. Video has nothing on ratings requests, judging, scores, and interestingness obsession that fill groups and pollute comment streams.
Not everyone uses Flickr the same way, respect that. Flickr is what you make of it. For some people it is a vehicle to showcase and discuss new photography techniques, amazing photos, and technical know how. For some people? It is a great place to put that picture of their dog with that ridiculous hat online and the video that goes with it. Their usage of Flickr is as valid as the previous group. Me personally? Flickr is that messy room that has everything in it when I need it. There are photos and sets and collections tossed all over the place, titled and in an order that only I can make sense of. It is always there for me to grab for use in better, more organized ways like on this site or for use in ZCPhotography.com. I don’t link people to my actual Flickr page anymore, it is too generic. Some people’s Flickr page is literally the face of their photography business online. If that works for them fantastic. getting worked up because people don’t use the service the way you do seems silly. Everything you have done with Flickr? You can still do.
Groups of people on the internet absolutely love being offended. This isn’t just pinned on the Flickr community it is an internet wide thing. People get worked up when Flickr changes the interestingness algorithm. There will be protest explore photos and drama spilling into the forums but I hope Flickr keeps the video because it seems pretty handy.
Maybe some of the top users can just relax and work on their lame 365 project.